Greenwashing Labels

Greenwashing Labels: What does Organic mean? And Eco-Friendly, Sustainable, Fair Labor, and other green labels? With the growing concern for our environment and the need for ethical consumption, being familiar with these terms and being able to identify genuine eco-labels has become increasingly important. Find out when green labels can be used and how to recognize the fake ones.

Table of Content

The term greenwashing was coined by New York environmentalist Jay Westerveld in a 1986 essay about the hotel industry’s practice of placing notices in bedrooms promoting reuse of towels to “save the environment”. He noted that often little or no effort toward reducing energy waste was made by these institutions, although towel reuse saved them laundry costs. He concluded that often the real objective was increased profit and labeled this and other profitable-but-ineffective “environmentally-conscientious” acts as greenwashing.
Source: Wikipedia

Green Label Terminology: Definitions and Descriptions

In today’s eco-conscious world, a multitude of terms and labels surround products and practices that emphasize sustainability, ethics, and responsible consumption. Understanding these labels is essential for making informed choices. Below is a list of common green label terminology and brief descriptions for each:

• Eco-Friendly: Products labeled as “eco-friendly” are designed to minimize their environmental impact. They are often produced using sustainable materials and processes that reduce waste, energy consumption, and emissions.
• Sustainable: Sustainability focuses on meeting the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their needs. Sustainable products and practices aim to balance economic, social, and environmental factors for long-term well-being.
• Organic: Organic products, such as food or textiles, are produced without synthetic pesticides, chemical fertilizers, or genetic modification. They adhere to strict organic farming standards to promote healthier ecosystems and human health.
• Fair Labor: Labels related to fair labor practices indicate that products were made under ethical working conditions. They often certify that workers received fair wages, safe working environments, and other labor rights.
• Non-GMO (Non-Genetically Modified Organism): Non-GMO labels confirm that a product or its ingredients do not contain genetically modified organisms. This label appeals to consumers concerned about the potential environmental and health impacts of GMOs.
• Energy Star: Energy Star is a widely recognized label for energy efficiency. Products bearing this label meet or exceed strict energy performance standards, helping consumers reduce their energy consumption and lower greenhouse gas emissions.
• Fair Trade: Fair Trade certification ensures that products like coffee, cocoa, and textiles were sourced under fair trade principles. It guarantees fair prices, ethical labor practices, and community development in producer countries.

• Biodegradable: Biodegradable products are designed to break down naturally over time, reducing their impact on landfills and ecosystems. However, the rate and conditions of biodegradation may vary.
• Recycled: Recycled labels signify that a product is made from recycled materials, reducing the demand for new resources and diverting waste from landfills.
• Low Carbon Footprint: Products with a low carbon footprint are associated with minimal greenhouse gas emissions during production, transportation, and use. They contribute less to climate change.

Authenticity is the compass in the wilderness of greenwashing.

Margaretha Nannenberg

When is it allowed to label a product as ‘organic’?

• Non-GMO (Genetically Modified Organism): Organic products are usually non-GMO, meaning they are not genetically modified.
• No synthetic additives: Organic processed foods typically do not contain synthetic additives, preservatives, or artificial colors or flavors.
• Livestock raised with organic practices: In the case of organic animal products (e.g., meat, eggs, dairy), the animals are raised in conditions that adhere to organic standards, such as access to outdoor areas and organic feed.
• Strict record-keeping: Organic producers must maintain detailed records to demonstrate compliance with organic standards.
• Certification: Products that claim to be organic often need to be certified by a recognized organic certification body. This certification process involves inspections and adherence to organic standards.

There are different labeling categories based on the percentage of organic ingredients in a product:

• 100% Organic: Products in this category contain only organic ingredients. No synthetic additives or ingredients are allowed.
• Organic: These products contain a minimum percentage of organic ingredients, typically ranging from 95% to 99%. The remaining ingredients must be approved for use in organic products and be on a list of allowed non-organic ingredients.
• Made with Organic Ingredients: Products in this category contain at least 70% organic ingredients. The remaining non-organic ingredients must be produced without excluded methods (e.g., genetic engineering) and appear on a list of allowed ingredients.
• Specific Ingredient Claims: Some products may make claims related to specific ingredients (e.g., “Made with organic strawberries”). In this case, the specified ingredient(s) must be organic, but the rest of the product may not be.

The “organic” label primarily relates to how a product is cultivated, emphasizing agricultural practices and the use of synthetic inputs. It does not inherently imply anything about the labor practices involved in production. While some organic certification programs may include requirements related to fair labor, this aspect can vary significantly by organization and region.

Greenwashing Labels: ‘90% Natural’ Claims

The use of the term “natural” as a label for a product can be somewhat subjective and is subject to regulation and interpretation by authorities in different regions. “Natural” is a broad and often imprecise term that can lead to confusion and potential greenwashing if not used carefully. For example, products labeled as “90% natural” while consisting of a high percentage of water, can raise questions about the accuracy and transparency of the label. Here are some considerations:

• Transparency and Accuracy: The labeling should accurately reflect the composition of the product. If a product claims to be “90% natural,” consumers might reasonably expect that the vast majority of the product is made up of natural ingredients. A product with 80% “natural” water does not align with this expectation.
• Deceptive Marketing: Such labeling practices may be viewed as a form of greenwashing labels, where the label creates an impression that the product is more natural or eco-friendly than it truly is. Deceptive marketing can erode consumer trust.
• Consumer Expectations: Consumer expectations vary, and some may be concerned about the predominance of water in a product labeled as “natural.” They might wonder about the necessity of such high water content in a product making natural claims.
• Regulatory Compliance: Depending on the region, labeling regulations may require clear and accurate representation of product content. Greenwashing labels could potentially violate consumer protection laws or advertising standards.
• Ingredient Disclosure: The product label should provide a detailed list of ingredients in descending order by concentration. This allows consumers to make informed choices and understand the composition of the product.
• Certifications: Consider whether the product has received any third-party certifications that define what “natural” means in the context of that product type. Certifications can provide more clarity and credibility.

While there is no specific legal threshold for what constitutes a “natural” product in many regions, labeling practices should be accurate, transparent, and not misleading. Products labeled as “90% natural” but primarily consisting of water may raise concerns about transparency and the alignment of labeling with consumer expectations.

Eco-Friendly Labels: A Closer Look

“Eco-friendly” is a term used on labels to describe products and practices that are environmentally responsible and designed to have a reduced impact on the planet. It implies that the item or action is considerate of environmental sustainability, resource conservation, and pollution reduction. Eco-friendly products and practices aim to minimize harm to ecosystems, reduce waste, and promote responsible consumption.

Requirements for Using the Eco-Friendly Label

• Sustainable Sourcing: Eco-friendly products often need to be made from sustainably sourced materials. This means that the raw materials should be obtained in a way that does not deplete natural resources or harm ecosystems.
• Energy Efficiency: Products and practices may need to demonstrate energy efficiency, meaning they use less energy in their production or operation compared to conventional alternatives.
• Reduced Emissions: Eco-friendly items should aim to have a lower carbon footprint by producing fewer greenhouse gas emissions during their lifecycle.
• Waste Reduction: Practices and products may be required to minimize waste generation, promote recycling, or reduce landfill contributions.
• Biodegradability: Some eco-friendly products are designed to be biodegradable, meaning they can naturally break down over time, reducing their environmental impact.
• Non-Toxic: Eco-friendly products should typically be non-toxic or have lower levels of harmful chemicals to minimize harm to ecosystems and human health.
• Certifications: Some products may carry third-party certifications like the Green Seal, EcoLogo, or Cradle to Cradle, which provide assurance that they meet specific eco-friendly criteria.
• Transparency: Brands and manufacturers may need to provide transparency about their environmental practices and materials, allowing consumers to make informed choices.

Without standardized regulations, the term ‘eco-friendly’ can sometimes be used loosely or inaccurately for marketing purposes, which is why consumers need to research and verify the specific claims made by products and brands, especially in the context of greenwashing labels.

The Meaning Behind Sustainable or Durable Labels

The terms “sustainable” and “durable” goes beyond environmental considerations. They encompass the concept of meeting present needs without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs.

The term “durable” refers to products that are designed to last longer, reducing the need for frequent replacements. This contributes to a more sustainable lifestyle by reducing waste and resource consumption. Manufacturers should focus on using high-quality materials and implementing sturdy construction techniques to create products that can withstand the test of time.

Sustainability addresses three key pillars – environmental, social, and economic. This means that sustainable practices not only protect the environment but also prioritize social equity and economic viability. It involves efficient resource utilization, responsible production and consumption, and promoting social well-being, fair trade, and human rights.

Requirements for Using the Sustainable Label

The use of the “sustainable” label is not governed by a single, universal authority, and as such, the specific requirements for using this label can vary depending on the industry, product, and region. However, some common principles and considerations for products and practices bearing the “sustainable” label include:

• Environmental Impact Reduction: Sustainable products and practices should aim to reduce their environmental footprint, including minimizing energy consumption, greenhouse gas emissions, and resource use.
• Resource Conservation: They often involve responsible sourcing of materials and the conservation of natural resources, such as water and forests.
• Economic Viability: Sustainability also considers economic viability, meaning that products or practices must be economically feasible in the long term, without depleting resources or causing economic instability.
• Social Responsibility: Sustainable practices may involve fair labor practices, equitable distribution of benefits, and consideration of social impacts on communities affected by the product or process.
• Life Cycle Assessment: Some sustainable certifications require a life cycle assessment, which analyzes the environmental and social impacts of a product from production to disposal.
• Transparency: Brands and manufacturers may need to be transparent about their sustainability practices, materials, and sourcing, allowing consumers to make informed choices.
• Third-Party Certifications: Some products and practices are certified as sustainable by independent organizations or bodies, such as the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) for sustainable forestry practices or LEED certification for sustainable building construction. The Cradle to Cradle Certified™ program is a well-known and respected certification system that assesses products and materials for their environmental and social sustainability throughout their entire life cycle. It evaluates factors such as material health, recyclability, renewable energy use, water stewardship, and social fairness. Products that receive Cradle to Cradle certification are recognized for their commitment to sustainable and circular design principles, making them suitable for inclusion in discussions about sustainable labels.
• Local Considerations: Sustainability can also consider local or regional factors, adapting practices to the specific environmental and societal contexts.

The Meaning Behind Fair Labor Labels

The term “fair labor,” when used on labels, indicates that the product or service has been produced or provided with a strong emphasis on ethical and humane labor practices. It implies that workers involved in the production or provision of the labeled item have been treated fairly, with respect to their rights, wages, working conditions, and overall well-being. Fair labor labels aim to ensure that workers are not exploited, and they promote social justice and equity.

Requirements for Using the Fair Labor or Ethical Label

• Respect for Labor Rights: Fair labor practices require that workers have the right to form labor unions, collectively bargain, and engage in fair labor practices without fear of discrimination or retaliation.
• Fair Wages: Workers should receive wages that provide for their basic needs and enable a decent standard of living. Fair labor labels may require employers to pay wages that exceed legal minimums.
• Safe and Healthy Working Conditions: Fair labor certification often includes standards for workplace safety and hygiene, ensuring that workers are not subjected to hazardous or unhealthy conditions.
• No Child Labor or Forced Labor: Fair labor labels typically prohibit child labor (workers under a certain age) and forced labor (workers compelled to work under threat or without consent).
• Equal Treatment: Workers should not be subjected to discrimination based on factors like gender, race, religion, or nationality. Fair labor labels promote equal treatment and opportunity.
• Freedom from Exploitation: Fair labor practices prohibit exploitative practices such as excessive working hours or withholding of wages.
• Transparency: Brands and manufacturers may be required to be transparent about their labor practices, including providing information about wages, working conditions, and workers’ rights.
• Third-Party Auditing: Some fair labor certifications involve third-party audits to ensure compliance with established labor standards.
• Community Benefits: Fair labor practices often consider the well-being of the local communities where products are produced, ensuring that communities benefit positively from production activities.
• Certification: Products bearing a fair labor label typically must be certified by a recognized certifying body or organization that verifies compliance with fair labor standards.

There are various fair labor certification organizations and standards (e.g., Fair Trade, the Fair Labor Association, etc.), each with its own specific criteria and focus. By supporting products that adhere to fair labor standards, consumers play a vital role in promoting social justice and human dignity.

Remember that an eco-label is just one piece of the puzzle. Assess a product’s entire lifecycle to gauge its sustainability.

Alex Walker, Eco-conscious Shopper

Biodegradable Label Meaning

The “biodegradable” label signifies that a product or material is capable of breaking down naturally into harmless substances when exposed to environmental conditions such as moisture, sunlight, and microorganisms. Biodegradable products are designed to reduce waste and environmental impact by decomposing over time, typically without leaving behind harmful residues.

Requirements for Using the Biodegradable Label

The use of the “biodegradable” label may not always be regulated consistently, and specific requirements can vary by region. General principles associated with the use of this label are:

• Proven Biodegradability: Products bearing this label should be scientifically tested and proven to break down under specific environmental conditions within a reasonable timeframe.
• Non-Toxic Breakdown: Biodegradation should result in harmless substances, and the breakdown process should not release toxic byproducts that harm the environment.
• Environmental Safety: Biodegradable products should not negatively impact ecosystems or wildlife during the decomposition process.
• Transparency: Manufacturers may be expected to provide information on the specific conditions required for biodegradation and the expected timeline for decomposition.

The Meaning of “Recycled” Labels

The “recycled” label indicates that a product or material contains recycled content, meaning it has been made using materials recovered from waste or discarded items. This label promotes recycling and the reduction of resource consumption.

Requirements for Using the Recycled Label

The requirements for using the “recycled” label can vary depending on the product or industry. Common considerations include:

• Minimum Recycled Content: Products must contain a specified percentage of post-consumer or post-industrial recycled materials. The minimum content can vary by product category and labeling standards.
• Verified Recycled Content: Manufacturers may need to provide evidence or verification of the recycled content in their products.
• Transparency: Companies should be transparent about the source and percentage of recycled materials used in their products.

Low Carbon Footprint Label Meaning

Requirements for Using the Low Carbon Footprint Label

The use of a “low carbon footprint” label is often not standardized and can vary widely. Requirements for using such a label might include:

• Carbon Emission Reduction: Products or activities should demonstrate quantifiable reductions in greenhouse gas emissions compared to conventional alternatives.
• Life Cycle Assessment: A thorough life cycle assessment may be required to evaluate emissions at all stages, from production to disposal.
• Carbon Offsetting: Some labels may allow for carbon offsetting through investments in projects that reduce or capture emissions, such as reforestation or renewable energy initiatives.

Climate Neutral or Carbon Neutral Labels

Requirements for Using the Climate Neutral or Carbon Neutral Label

The specific requirements and criteria for using a “Climate Neutral” or “Carbon Neutral” label can vary among organizations and certification programs. However, here are common principles and considerations often associated with achieving and using the label:

• Emissions Assessment: To use the label, an entity (such as a company, product, or event) typically needs to conduct a comprehensive assessment of its greenhouse gas emissions. This assessment includes measuring emissions from all relevant sources, including direct emissions (e.g., from operations) and indirect emissions (e.g., from the supply chain).
• Emissions Reduction: The entity should implement measures to reduce its emissions. This may involve improving energy efficiency, transitioning to renewable energy sources, optimizing transportation, and adopting sustainable practices to minimize emissions.
• Offsetting Emissions: Any remaining emissions that cannot be eliminated through reduction measures must be offset. Offset projects, such as reforestation, renewable energy development, or methane capture initiatives, are undertaken to remove or reduce an equivalent amount of greenhouse gases elsewhere.
• Third-Party Verification: Many credible Climate Neutral programs require third-party verification of emissions calculations, reduction efforts, and offset projects to ensure transparency and accuracy.
• Transparent Reporting: Organizations or entities using the label are often expected to provide transparent and detailed reporting on their emissions, reduction measures, and offsetting activities. This information should be accessible to the public.
• Continual Improvement: Commitment to continual improvement in emissions reduction and offsetting practices is essential. Organizations may need to set and work toward progressively more ambitious emissions reduction targets.
• Stakeholder Engagement: Engaging stakeholders, including employees, customers, and partners, in climate action and reporting is encouraged.
• Promotion of Climate Neutrality: Organizations using the label may actively promote their Climate Neutral status to raise awareness and inspire action on climate change among consumers and peers.

How does an Emissions Assessment look like?

The “Emissions Assessment” for achieving the Climate Neutral or Carbon Neutral status, it typically includes a comprehensive evaluation of all greenhouse gas emissions associated with a product, service, organization, or event. This assessment encompasses the major greenhouse gases that contribute to global warming and climate change. These gases are often referred to as “Kyoto Protocol gases” and include:

• Carbon Dioxide (CO₂): CO₂ emissions result primarily from the combustion of fossil fuels, such as gasoline and coal, for energy production, transportation, and industrial processes.
• Methane (CH₄): Methane emissions often originate from sources such as livestock digestion, natural gas production and distribution, landfills, and certain agricultural practices.
• Nitrous Oxide (N₂O): N₂O emissions are associated with agricultural activities, the use of synthetic fertilizers, and certain industrial processes.
• Hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs), Perfluorocarbons (PFCs), and Sulfur Hexafluoride (SF₆): These are synthetic greenhouse gases found in various industrial applications, including refrigeration, air conditioning, and electronics manufacturing.

The emissions assessment involves quantifying emissions from all of these greenhouse gases, and it may include other gases or substances depending on the specific assessment and program. The assessment process typically considers both direct emissions (e.g., emissions from combustion) and indirect emissions (e.g., emissions associated with electricity use and supply chain activities).

Methane emissions are an essential component of greenhouse gas assessments, as methane is a potent greenhouse gas with a much higher global warming potential than carbon dioxide over a short time frame. Therefore, organizations and programs that aim to achieve Climate Neutral or Carbon Neutral status should account for and address methane emissions, along with other greenhouse gases, in their assessments and reduction strategies.

Greenwashing Labels: Deceptive Marketing Tactics

Marketers may engage in “greenwashing” when using labels like “organic”, “eco-friendly”, “natural”, “environmentally friendly” etc. to make their products appear more environmentally friendly or ethical than they truly are. Greenwashing labels involves deceptive or misleading marketing practices that exaggerate or falsely represent a product’s environmental or ethical qualities. Here are some common tactics marketers might use to greenwash labels:

• Vague Terminology: Marketers may use ambiguous terms like “natural,” “eco-friendly,” or “green” without providing clear evidence of organic practices.
• Exaggerated Claims: They might make exaggerated or unverified claims about the environmental benefits of a product, such as claiming it’s “100% organic” when only a small percentage of the ingredients are organic.
• Misleading Imagery: Using images of lush green fields or natural landscapes on packaging can create a false impression of the product’s origin or environmental impact.
• Incomplete Information: Providing limited or selective information about a product’s organic certification, omitting information about non-organic ingredients, or failing to disclose certain practices.
• Unsubstantiated Certifications: Marketers might display unofficial or deceptive certification seals to mislead consumers into thinking a product is certified organic when it isn’t.
• Comparative Greenwashing: Comparing a product to a non-existent or lower environmental standard to make it seem more eco-friendly.
• Confusing Labels: Designing labels that closely resemble official organic certification logos, but with subtle differences that can mislead consumers.
• Hidden Trade-Offs: Focusing on one aspect of a product’s sustainability while ignoring other negative environmental or ethical impacts.

Greenwashing is like putting lipstick on a pig. It might look better on the surface, but it doesn’t change the underlying reality.

John Smith, Environmental Activist

What to pay attention to in order to Avoid Falling for Greenwashed Labels

To avoid falling for greenwashing labels, consumers should look for official certification labels or seals from reputable certifying bodies.

Additionally, conducting independent research, reading ingredient lists, and seeking transparency in a company’s sustainability practices can empower consumers to make more informed choices and avoid products deceptively marketed as eco-friendly, natural, carbon neutral, or any other term they want to greenwash their labels with.

Furthermore, it’s crucial to investigate the brand or company behind the product. Check if they have a track record of sustainability and ethical practices. Companies genuinely committed to the environment often provide accessible information about their sustainable initiatives.

When you have doubts about the authenticity of green labels applied to products, consider the following strategies:

• Consumer Protection Websites: Visit websites dedicated to consumer protection, such as Consumer Reports or the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) in the United States. These organizations frequently spotlight and dissect deceptive marketing tactics.
• Consumer Forums and Discussions: Delve into online consumer forums, blogs, and social media groups where consumers share their experiences with misleading product labeling. They often share visual examples of deceptive labels.
• News Articles: Search for news articles or investigative reports that have exposed instances of deceptive labeling in various industries. Investigative journalism often features visual examples of such practices.
• Organic Certification Bodies: Refer to the websites of well-established organic certification bodies and organizations in your region. They often offer resources and guidelines to help consumers distinguish genuine certification labels from misleading ones.
• Online Retailers: While shopping online, exercise caution when encountering product listings using logos or labels that closely mimic official certifications. Many online marketplaces have policies against deceptive labeling, so reporting such listings can be beneficial.

Remember, it’s essential to stay informed, think critically, and make choices that align with your values and the greater good of the planet. Together, we can create a more eco-friendly, sustainable, and socially just world.

Frequently Asked Questions